It’s been another good year of eating.
Yes, 2006 has brought a surfeit of culinary riches to Brooklyn
- and with them, of course, a few trends. Nearly every chef I
spoke to is "sourcing mostly organic ingredients from sustainable,
small farms."
And more small-plate eateries opened - some that actually serve
single portions on small plates.
This year also saw foie gras-topped designer burgers taking
their place beside classic cheeseburgers; and pastry chefs are
realizing just how good it is to pair something sweet with something
salty.
Narrowing the group of great eateries that I reviewed for GO
Brooklyn over the past 12 months down to 10 for this annual year-in-review
roundup wasn’t easy, so I added an honorable mention section
to acknowledge talented runner-ups.
But don’t assume anything by the order of the places listed.
Like a good mother, I’m not picking favorites among the group.
I’ll just say I admire each restaurant equally.
I fell for Baci &
Abbracci, which is all "hip Williamsburg" on the
inside yet reflects the soul of an Italian grandmother in the
cooking. I sat in the restaurant’s roomy garden one balmy summer
night, drank wine and shared the best pizza I’ve had all year.
Pizzaiolo Frank Mastelione turned out an ethereal, char-crusted
beauty with a crisp, flavorful crust and smoked mozzarella, pancetta
and caramelized onion toppings.
Just thinking of that pie makes my heart thump.
Former chef Franco Migliorine (Stephano Scala is now behind
the stove) turned out penne with a briny anchovy sauce that was
as bracing as a dive into the drink.
People appreciate a good deed, especially if it means offering
fine food to an underserved community. The locals of Ditmas Park
let Allison McDowell and Gary Jonas know just how happy they
were with The Farm on Adderley,
by packing the place every evening since its launch in July.
Chef Tom Kearney’s summer menu featured a cauliflower soup with
a plump oyster fritter that was all about the perfect harmonizing
of the two ingredients. And he decided that enough was enough
with banal desserts and put something on the menu that knocked
diners off their mismatched wooden seats: A silky chocolate mousse
with a dollop of truly salty, soft whipped cream. You can still
order the dessert.
"Our customers would revolt if we ever got rid of it,"
says McDowell.
I like Japanese food as much as the next girl, but by last spring,
I had consumed one too many ho-hum designer rolls. That’s the
reason it took me a few months to get over to Nouvelle,
a pan-Asian eatery that opened in September.
I was sorry I waited so long.
This modern, Bay Ridge restaurant and lounge serves as the showcase
for chef Andy Yang’s dishes. Before joining the restaurant, Yang
was the executive chef at Nobu in Los Angeles, owned by Nobu
Matsuhisa.
I ordered the "Omikase," or chef’s choice, a tasting
menu of what seemed like 200 dishes. (Reality brings the number
down to a still-hefty six.)
There’s one dish that I doubt I’ll forget (and the way I eat,
that’s saying a lot): The "Mission 06." The pieces
of raw tuna, striped bass and Spanish mackerel resembled a flower
and tasted as if it bloomed in the mouth. Iced with a thin layer
of black caviar, a small mound of sweet lobster meat and a quail
egg, it was pure decadence and pure pleasure.
(Yang is now a consultant to the restaurant. The new chef, Steve
Ling, executes many of Yang’s recipes.)
There were sad faces on Smith Street when Adam Shepard pulled
the plug on Taku, his well-respected but under-patronized Japanese
restaurant. It turns out, he’s as good at bold Italian fare as
he is at Asian cuisine. Lunetta,
his small plate eatery, opened in the same Smith Street location
in October. Like its predecessor, Lunetta possesses that distinctly
Brooklyn, homey-yet-chic ambience. His artichokes, sliced into
razor thin shards and perfumed with rosemary, are fried so crisp
they crackle, then disappear, on the tongue.
And, once you’ve tasted his fried chicken with sweet and tart
"agrodolce" sauce, you’ll never think of the bird as
something to pair with biscuits and mashed potatoes again.
Not far from Lunetta on Smith Street is Porchetta,
an amusing Italian eatery that opened in July. Inspired by the
restaurant’s ingratiating mascot, chef Jason Neroni served an
unctuous fried pork belly with a brittle crust, over nutty, "melted"
cauliflower. He deepened the dish’s flavor with dried figs marinated
in red wine.
Equally lush was a "raviolo," a single, loosely assembled
ravioli filled with sauteed mushrooms. He topped the pasta square
with a poached egg and a grating of sharp Parmesan cheese.
I’d almost forgotten about Cocotte
in Park Slope when I heard owners Christine and Bill Snell hired
a new executive chef, Adam Ross. My visit there last spring,
followed by several more over the months, reminded me of why
this place continues to be such a gem. Ross’s bowl of fresh,
slightly chilled pea soup was like inhaling the scent of a dew-sparkled
garden. He played up the sweetness of the vegetable with a strip
of salty, brittle pancetta.
A location off of Fifth and Seventh avenues, Park Slope’s two
restaurant rows, may be the reason that the American bistro,
Melt, doesn’t get as much buzz
as more conspicuously placed eateries. Chef Brian Bunger’s pan-seared
shrimp with jalapeño-cucumber relish; his opulent, crisp,
quail with foie gras; and fabulously crunchy frites with aioli
made great eating. (The new executive chef, Kevin Milisauskas,
started in November; his menu has similar American bistro-style
dishes.)
Another Park Slope winner that opened in July is Palo
Santo. At the helm of this eclectic Latin eatery and wine
bar is chef-owner Jacques Gautier. His smoky tuna - seared just
until the edges are charred, and partnered with lightly dressed
string beans and radish slivers - is an example of the chef’s
insouciant style of ingredient pairing.
Like Melt, Royal’s Downtown
may be too hidden away for its own good. Situated on a shady,
brownstone-lined street in Carroll Gardens, the elegant bistro
is a bit too far from the area’s action to attract much foot
traffic. Too bad for those who miss this spot. Once there, the
service is pampering without being intrusive, and the food is
thoughtfully prepared and creative. And inside, it’s like stumbling
into a quirky, old countryside inn with a roaring fireplace.
Chef Alex McWilliams (who has since moved on and been replaced
by his sous chef, Omar Clemente, formerly of Le Bernardin) prepared
a risotto scattered with white truffles and dusted with Parmesan.
It was rich, yet silky and light with an aroma both woodsy and
sharp.
I loved it.
I also fell for McWilliams’s goat cheese cheesecake with a swirl
of pomegranate and lavender syrup.
Sea bass, wrapped in thin potato slices then roasted, was an
iconic dish in the 1980s. I’d almost forgotten about it, until
this summer when I noticed the entree on the menu at Black
Pearl, another excellent Park Slope restaurant that opened
in November 2005. Chef Alfredo Duarte seared the filet to crisp
the potato cloak, and then slow-roasted it until the center was
like moist silk. Caramelized fennel and leeks served as a licorice-tinged
bed for the fish. It’s still on the menu and worth a trip over.
That’s the Top 10 for 2006. Whether they made the list or were
included in the honorable mention below, all the talented chefs
who fed me so well this year receive my thanks.
Honorable mentions
Bay Ridge’s Amelia’s Ristorante
because chef Ken Deiner is in the kitchen turning out exuberant,
sophisticated Italian fare; Gribouille
in Williamsburg for its hearty, French classics that include
a robust hanger steak "au poivre" and lush potato gratin;
Provence en Boite
on Smith Street for the "Le Jean-Jacques burger,"
a pile of short ribs, black truffles and foie gras that’s worth
every penny of its $25 tab; and Habana
Outpost in Fort Greene for owner Sean Meenan, who puts his
money where his mouth is and does good for the community in so
many ways. (His solar-powered restaurant/flea market is equipped
with a smoothie-making "bike blender" that you have
to see to believe.)
I have to acknowledge Fairway, the mother of all supermarkets,
for its fantastic, well-priced selection of everything, and a
waterside cafe that offers an unparalleled view of Lady Liberty
and the city beyond.
Baci & Abbracci (204 Grand St.
between Driggs and Bedford avenues in Williamsburg) accepts American
Express, MasterCard and Visa. Entrees: $14-$24. Lunch and dinner
are served daily. Brunch is available on weekends, from noon
to 4 pm. Subway: L to Bedford Avenue. For reservations and more
information, call (718) 599-6599 or visit the Web site, www.baciabbracciny.com.
Black Pearl (833 Union St. between Sixth and Seventh avenues
in Park Slope) accepts American Express, Diner’s Club, Discover,
MasterCard and Visa. Entrees: $12-$28. The restaurant serves
dinner daily. Brunch is available on weekends, from 11 am to
3:30 pm. Subway: R to Union Street. For reservations, call (718)
857-2004.
Cocotte (337 Fifth Ave. at Fourth Street in Park Slope) accepts
MasterCard and Visa. Entrees: $13-$23. The restaurant serves
dinner Tuesday through Sunday. Brunch is available, from 11 am
to 3 pm, on weekends. Closed Mondays. Subway: F to 9th Street;
R, M to Fourth Avenue. For more information or reservations,
call (718) 832-6848 or visit the Web site, www.cocotterestaurant.com.
Lunetta (116 Smith St. between Dean and Pacific streets in Boerum
Hill) accepts American Express, MasterCard and Visa. Dishes:
$3-$16. Dinner is available Tuesday through Sunday. Closed Mondays.
Subway: F or G to Bergen Street. For more information, call (718)
488-6269 or visit the Web site, www.lunetta-ny.com.
Melt (440 Bergen St. between Fifth and Sixth avenues in Park
Slope) accepts MasterCard and Visa. Entrees: $16-$23. The restaurant
serves dinner daily and brunch on weekends, from 11 am to 4 pm.
Subway: 2, 3 to Bergen Street. For reservations, call (718) 230-5925.
Nouvelle (8716 Third Ave. between 87th and 88th streets in Bay
Ridge) accepts American Express, Discover, MasterCard and Visa.
Entrees: $12-$22. "Omikase" is $50 for five courses.
The restaurant serves lunch and dinner daily. Subway: R to 86th
Street. For more information or reservations, call (718) 238-8250
or visit the Web site www.nouvellerestaurant.com.
Palo Santo (652 Union St. between Fourth and Fifth avenues in
Park Slope) accepts cash only. Entrees: $15-$25. Breakfast, lunch
and dinner are served daily. Brunch is available, from 10 am
to 4 pm, on weekends. Subway: R to Union Street. For more information,
call (718) 636-6311 or visit the Web site, www.palosanto.us.
Porchetta (241 Smith St. at Douglass Street in Boerum Hill)
accepts American Express, MasterCard and Visa. Entrees: $17-$20.
The restaurant serves dinner daily. Each evening, a three-course,
$25 prix-fixe dinner is offered. Brunch is available on weekends,
from 10 am to 4 pm. Subway: F, G to Bergen Street. For reservations,
call (718) 237-9100.
Royal’s Downtown (215 Union St. between Clinton and Henry streets
in Carroll Gardens) accepts American Express, MasterCard and
Visa. Entrees: $18-$32. The restaurant serves dinner Tuesday
through Saturday. Closed Sundays and Mondays. Subway: F, G to
Carroll Street. For more information or reservations, call (718)
923-9866 or visit the Web site, www.royalsdowntown.com.
The Farm on Adderley (1108 Cortelyou Rd. between Stratford and
Westminster roads in Ditmas Park) accepts American Express, Discover,
MasterCard and Visa. Entrees: $11-$16. The restaurant serves
dinner daily. Brunch is available on weekends, from 11 am to
4 pm. Subway: Q to Cortelyou Road. For more information or reservations,
call (718) 287-3101 or visit the Web site at www.thefarmonadderley.com.
©2006 The Brooklyn Paper
By submitting this comment, you agree to the following terms:
You agree that you, and not BrooklynPaper.com or its affiliates, are fully responsible for the content that you post. You agree not to post any abusive, obscene, vulgar, slanderous, hateful, threatening or sexually-oriented material or any material that may violate applicable law; doing so may lead to the removal of your post and to your being permanently banned from posting to the site. You grant to BrooklynPaper.com the royalty-free, irrevocable, perpetual and fully sublicensable license to use, reproduce, modify, adapt, publish, translate, create derivative works from, distribute, perform and display such content in whole or in part world-wide and to incorporate it in other works in any form, media or technology now known or later developed.