What killed the A&S name? How about ‘Miracle on 34th Street’?

Brooklyn Paper
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Brooklyn Paper Radio

It’s Santa’s fault!

Brooklyn’s beloved A&S became a Macy’s instead of keeping its iconic moniker because St. Nicholas himself made the Manhattan department store a household name in the movie “Miracle on 34th Street,” a historian announced on the latest edition of Brooklyn Paper Radio.

Author and oboist Michael Lisicky told host and Brooklyn Paper editor-in-chief Vince DiMiceli that if not for the Natalie Wood movie, the A&S name could have been plastered across America instead of ending up on the scrapheap of American retail.

“It all goes back to the movie you loved so much as a kid,” Lisicky told DiMiceli on the show. “Because of that, people wanted Macy’s to come to town, and not A&S.”

In fact, A&S was sitting on the top of the food chain at Federated Department Stores when that company bought Macy’s, and the rest, as they say in the business, is history.

Soon after, the store loved so much by the likes of Brooklyn newspaper tycoon Ed Weintrob (another guest on the show) became just a footnote in the retail history books.

But for more than 100 years, Abraham and Straus, as it was officially called, anchored Brooklyn’s Downtown shopping district along Fulton Street. In its heyday in the 1940s, the store employed more than 2,400 full-timers (who enjoyed a card room, gymnasium, hospital, and employee library) and welcomed an average of 70,000 customers a day.

For years, Brooklynites eschewed Macy’s and Gimbels on the other side of the river in favor of the Brooklyn-born behemoth, where they could buy clothes, liquor, ice cream, appliances, and even have dinner in its fifth-floor restaurant.

They even had a song they sang to cheer their department store over the one founded by R.H. Macy — and later by the same clan that ran A&S before a family squabble split the two stores up.

“I won’t go to Macy’s any more, more more, ’cause there’s a big fat policeman at the door door door,” DiMiceli, whose grandmother only shopped at what many in Brooklyn called “A&S’s” recalled. “He’ll pull you by the collar, and make you pay a dollar, so I won’t go to Macy’s any more more more.”

The Downtown A&S remained the flagship of a retail empire that featured stores in Long Island, New Jersey, Philadelphia, and even one in Manhattan.

Lisicky’s new book “Abraham and Straus: It’s Worth the Trip from Anywhere” chronicles the store’s history from its beginnings as Abraham and Wechler’s to its transition to Macy’s in the early 1990s.

But the author, who’s also written about Gimbels, Filene’s, Bamberger’s and Wanamaker’s among others, was happy to learn the newly refurbished Macy’s on Fulton Street, though much smaller than its predecessor, is still there.

“You have something to be proud of in Brooklyn,” he said. “Downtown department stores are going away, and you still have one.”

Brooklyn Paper radio is recorded and podcast live almost every Tuesday at 3:30 pm — for your convenience — from our studio in America’s Downtown and can be found, as always, on, on iTunes, and of course, on Stitcher.

Updated 5:52 pm, July 9, 2018
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Reasonable discourse

Morris from Mill Basin says:
I learned the poem this way:

I won't go to Macy's any more, more, more
There's a big fat policeman at the door, door, door
He'll squeeze you like a lemon
A kalatchgazolenemon
No I won't go to Macy's any more.
Nov. 29, 2017, 2:15 pm
Henry Ford from Bay Ridge says:
A&S always has better deals, and was more popular with working class people. Macy’s was always overpriced.
Nov. 30, 2017, 11:56 pm
Janice Aubrey from Brooklyn Heights says:
Hi! Read your article about author Michael Lisicky. Plan to read some of his books; they all sound interesting. The reason I'm writing is to request that perhaps you can help me to send a note to Mr. Lisicky. My sister who just recently passed away was herself a local historian (Western PA) with three published books about Lawrence County; she was also a noted publisher/editor in the Washington D.C. area for most of her life. Most importantly, she was an oboist like Mr. Lisicky. When she passed away I was responsible for seeing that her personal effects were properly distributed. Something I'm left with is an oboe (not of great value I don't think) and a large box filled with reed-making equipment. I believe she mentioned to me once that these tools were far more valuable than her instrument, some of them vintage and perhaps highly collectible. She had no idea what to do with them and this is why I would like to be in touch with Mr. Lisicky. Perhaps he could advise me. Would you be willing to help? (
Dec. 4, 2017, 5:30 pm
Ron Schweiger from Flatbush/Flatlands says:
The original store, Wechsler & Abraham opened in 1865. It was on Fulton Street but at a different location. Isador and Nathan Straus joined Mr. Abraham in the early 1890's and the name changed to Abraham & Straus. All three, Abraham, Isador and Nathan, we're millionaire philanthropists. In 1912, the Straus brothers were visiting Palestine. When they were to return home to New York that year, Nathan decided to stay a bit longer. Isador never made it home for he was on the TITANIC. The city of Natanya, Israel is named for Nathan Straus.
My wife and I have an A & S shopping bag framed with 3 of our A & S credit cards, hanging in our home. The best store!!!
Dec. 8, 2017, 5:21 pm

Comments closed.

First name
Last name
Your neighborhood
Email address
Daytime phone

Your letter must be signed and include all of the information requested above. (Only your name and neighborhood are published with the letter.) Letters should be as brief as possible; while they may discuss any topic of interest to our readers, priority will be given to letters that relate to stories covered by The Brooklyn Paper.

Letters will be edited at the sole discretion of the editor, may be published in whole or part in any media, and upon publication become the property of The Brooklyn Paper. The earlier in the week you send your letter, the better.

Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: