Astroland is truly dead

The Brooklyn Paper
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Astroland will close for good on Sunday.

The operator of the 46-year-old amusement park announced on Thursday afternoon that she would shut down the gritty theme park because Thor Equities, its landlord, would not meet her deadline for a two-year lease extension.

“I have given up on trying to get Thor to negotiate which I have attempted to do every month since June, and numerous times in August,” Carol Albert wrote in a statement. “Each time their response was, ‘We have no answer.’”

Albert has been Thor’s tenant for the last two years after she sold the land under the 3.1-acre theme park to Joe Sitt’s company for $30 million in 2006. Her current lease lasts until Jan. 31, though the seasonal park with 75 full-time employees and 275 summer workers typically closes after Labor Day.

Last year, Albert also played brinksmanship with Thor after the summer season ended. But in that case, Thor Equities did offer a one-year lease extension in October that enabled this season’s fun.

This time, Albert said she was unwilling to wait to make a deal and set Thursday as the deadline.

It came and passed without an offer from Thor. Now, she’s holding a fire sale to unload her rides.

“I have 16 trailers of everything from teddy bears to tools, plus 22 rides and I’m selling everything,” she told The Brooklyn Paper.

Sitt’s spokesman Stefan Friedman said he was disappointed.

“Carol Albert was walking away from Coney Island,” Friedman said.

Friedman also said there would be new amusements and attractions next summer at the Astroland site, near the corner of Surf Avenue and West 10th Street.

But Thor had dubbed the season as the “Summer of Hope,” and Sitt’s efforts to infuse optimism on the sandy peninsula with new rides and attractions was widely criticized for the poor quality of the amusements and their short stints in the area.

Sitt is one of the major landowners in Coney Island’s amusement area and, like Albert, many other businesses along the Boardwalk have year-to-year leases with him.

They were scrambling to regroup and chart a course of action in the aftermath of the Astroland announcement compounded the uncertainty about their own futures.

“We all hope we’re going to get our leases renewed,” said Diana Carlin, the operator of the Lola Staar boutique on the Boardwalk, a Thor tenant, and the Dreamland Roller Rink, which is not owned by Thor.

The battle over Astroland is playing out as the larger war over the long-term future of Coney Island is still being fought between Sitt and Mayor Bloomberg. Both sides are pushing slightly different plans to redevelop the fabled, yet rundown, “People’s Playground” into a modern, year-round tourist destination.

The city seized upon Astroland’s closing as a way to push for its own rezoning plan.

“Today’s announcement that Astroland will close after 46 years should be a serious wake-up call to those who have stood back and watched as the fate of Coney Island has been left in limbo without any safeguards for its future,” said Lynn Kelly, president of the Coney Island Development Corporation. “This further underscores the need for the city’s comprehensive rezoning plan as the only hope for preserving the amusement area and bringing the necessary jobs, infrastructure and affordable housing to the neighborho­od.”

But that plan calls for building a city-owned amusement park that would have forced Astroland out too, a proposal which gets just as much scathing criticism as Thor’s impasse with its tenants.

“I also condemn the city because it has no authentic vision for how to keep the amusement industry vibrant and in business,” said Dick Zigun, who founded the Coney Island Circus Sideshow and resigned in protest earlier this summer from the Coney Island Development Corporation’s board over the city’s own proposal.

Updated 5:08 pm, July 9, 2018
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Reasonable discourse

mark from park slope says:
what a shame a historical place will be closed,shame on thesepeople who value profits over nostalgia and want to make coney island look like another casino area.
Sept. 5, 2008, 3:04 pm
Fara Shimbo from Midwood says:
The only thing I can say is.... this is a genuine shandah. Amusement parks are what made Coney Island what it is. Taking away the last one ranks with the Dodgers leaving and the Trolleys ceasing operation as a remarkably egregious attempt to make Brooklyn just another place.
Sept. 5, 2008, 11:31 pm
Michael from Park Slope says:
The death of Astroland was more than expected yet poignant nonetheless. As a child, I remember when it opened: a state of the art playground, if only modestly so, that rapidly descended into neglect but defiant (like Coney Island itself) in the face of it all. To paraphrase Robert Frost, the death of a love or a season could only be a treason if were to be carelessly accepted.
Sept. 6, 2008, 12:53 am
coney girl from coney island says:
The city has wasted 4 years and mucho bucks (how much I would like to know) on a so called Strategic Plan that wouldn't bebuilt till 2010. Yet they don't have an interim plan for Coney Island? How farsighted of them. well, I'm sure they all had a lovely vacation on their taxpayer funded jaunt to England, Denmark, Holland and Florida in search of a model for Coney Island's future amusement parks. The sad sad truth is we'll never see a Tivoli in Coney Island. Thor's Future of Coney Island is premeditated urban blight followed by shopping mall and high rises. Or followed by flip the property for millions after the rezoning.

Shame on the city for standing by and allowing Thor equities to wreck Coney Island! That's what we get for having a City Councilman whose name is Dominic Wreckia and a very good friend of Thor's. That's what we get for having a Mayor who is hell bent on rezoning the city without regard for anyone who is not arich New Yorker. Goodbye Astroland, Goodbye Coney Island!
Sept. 6, 2008, 8:56 am
Ace from New Utrecht says:
"premeditated urban blight" -exactly.
Sept. 8, 2008, 1:22 pm
Kimba Wiggins from formerly Fort Greene says:
Coney Island is really going downhill. I can't believe Astroland is closing. The last time I was in Coney Island was in 2003. I haven't gone back because it doesn't feel the same anymore.
Sept. 8, 2008, 8:55 pm
Jenny from Formerly Park Slope says:
I have two words, BS!
Sept. 8, 2008, 10:48 pm
mizzle from columbus OH says:
by some lucky twist of fate, i just happened to be in NYC last weekend and was able to spend a day at coney island. it was the first time i had been there, but i was absolutely smitten with its kitsch, grit, and quaint charm. i am sorry for fellow denizens who did not have the opportunity to enjoy the sights & flavors of CI. no one i talked to even agreed with the gentrification plan... whose city is it anyway?
Sept. 9, 2008, 10:46 am
Paul A. Toomey from Bay Ridge/Ft. Hamilton says:
Another piece of New York history has been written off. Coney has been part of the city that has been unique since Charles Feltman opened his small saloon in 1871. The beach,games and rides were known as the working mans Riviera. Astro Land and the other amusements will never be replaced by Thor Ent. whose idea of Coney Island is high-rise hotels/con-dos and mini malls. Sitt tried a fake-out with his Summer of Hope rides that lasted all of half the month of july. The people that were employed at Astro Land are now out of work. The remaining establishments Rubys and Cha-Chas and the other venders are only a matter of time before they too are gone. I wonder if when Thor builds their verision of Coney,will they charge to get on to the beach? Alas, poor Coney,I knew you well....PAT
Sept. 13, 2008, 1:42 pm

Comments closed.

First name
Last name
Your neighborhood
Email address
Daytime phone

Your letter must be signed and include all of the information requested above. (Only your name and neighborhood are published with the letter.) Letters should be as brief as possible; while they may discuss any topic of interest to our readers, priority will be given to letters that relate to stories covered by The Brooklyn Paper.

Letters will be edited at the sole discretion of the editor, may be published in whole or part in any media, and upon publication become the property of The Brooklyn Paper. The earlier in the week you send your letter, the better.

Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: