Quantcast

Together Brooklyn stands: Borough unites for touching 9/11 tributes

Bay Ridge 9/11 Vigil
People gather for a 9/11 vigil at the American Veterans Memorial Pier in Bay Ridge on Wednesday, Sept. 11, 2024 — one of many commemorations held across the borough.
Photo by Paul Frangipane

Brooklyn came together this week to honor the memory of those lost on Sept. 11, 2001 with a series of poignant commemorations, memorials and tributes spread across the borough.

From solemn ceremonies at the Brooklyn Heights Promenade to reflective gatherings at local firehouses and parks, the borough paid tribute to the resilience and unity that emerged from the tragedy, ensuring that the memories of the fallen were honored and preserved.

Patriot Day at Fort Hamilton

U.S. Army Garrison Fort Hamilton marked Patriot Day with its annual 9/11 National Day of Service and Remembrance Ceremony on Sept. 10, reflecting on the lives lost 23 years ago and honoring those who have since defended the nation.

Col. Melissa Cantwell, the base’s second female military officer in its 197-year history, addressed the gathering, calling it a “time to pay tribute.”

“It’s hard to believe it was 23 years ago — it feels like yesterday,” she said. “Every one of us remembers where we were on that day because we know freedom is not free. Men and women from all backgrounds have come together to serve this great nation selflessly, with the support of their families and civilians, continuing to build on our Army’s legacy of strength and resilience.”

A wreath was placed at the garrison’s 9/11 memorial by Garrison Commander Col. Melissa Cantwell, Garrison Command Sgt. Maj. Christopher Hill, U.S. Army Reserve Maj. Gen. Kris A. Belanger, commanding general, 99th Readiness Division, and CSM Corey A. Thompson, 99th Readiness Division.U.S. Army photos by Markl Getman/Fort Hamilton Garrison Public Affairs

The ceremony featured a 21-gun salute and the playing of taps. A wreath was placed at the garrison’s 9/11 memorial by Col. Cantwell, Garrison Command Sgt. Maj. Christopher Hill, U.S. Army Reserve Maj. Gen. Kris A. Belanger, commanding general of the 99th Readiness Division, and CSM Corey A. Thompson, also of the 99th Readiness Division.

Marine Park remembrance

A somber yet deeply moving 9/11 memorial ceremony unfolded at Marine Park on Wednesday, as community residents gathered to honor the memory of those who sacrificed their lives and those who continue to bear the weight of that tragic day.

The ceremony was marked by heartfelt tributes and poignant reflections from several speakers. Among them was Donald Cranston, who shared a personal and emotional account of his brother, NYPD Officer Brian Cranston. Brian Cranston, who had served at Ground Zero, succumbed to cancer linked to his work at the site. Struggling to hold back tears, Donald expressed the profound loss felt by his family and the ongoing impact of 9/11 on their lives.

Paul Curiale, a long-time community resident, emphasized the importance of keeping the memories of 9/11 alive. His remarks underscored the collective resolve of the community to remember and honor those who gave their all.

Community members gather in Marine Park for an emotional 9/11 memorial service.Photo by Arthur de Gaeta
Assembly Member Jaime Williams at the Marine Park memorial.Photo by Arthur de Gaeta

Democratic leader Frank Seddio recalled the harrowing moments of that day with vivid clarity.

“When the towers fell, my heart just sank, followed by a crushing blow to my beliefs and freedoms,” he said to a crowd in tears.

As the ceremony drew to a close, the Marine Park community united in a collective embrace, expressing their deep gratitude to first responders and honoring their continued commitment to keeping the community safe.

Asser Levy Park memorial

On Wednesday afternoon, locals and elected officials gathered at Asser Levy Park in Brighton Beach to pay tribute to the victims of the 9/11 attacks, with a special focus on the 18 Brooklynites memorialized on a plaque inside the park.

Attendees laid flowers and lit candles in a solemn tribute to those lost.

An audience member is overcome with emotion during this year’s Asser Levy Park 9/11 memorial.Photo By Erica Price

A number of local elected officials spoke at the event, including Council Members Justin Brannan and Inna Vernikov, and Assembly Members Alec Brook-Krasny, Helene Weinstein and Michael Novakhov. Solomiya Momot, Director of Constituent Services, represented New York State Senator Jessica Scarcella-Spanton.

Speakers at the memorial emphasized the importance of ensuring that future generations understand the events of 9/11. They stressed that many younger people have never met or remember family members who passed away in the attacks, highlighting the need to keep the memory of that day alive for those who weren’t there to witness it.

Valentina Lygin, who lost her son Alexander in the attacks, was also among the speakers, representing the deep personal and community loss felt on this anniversary.

Valentina Lygin, who lost her son Alexander in the attacks, addressed the crowd.Photo By Erica Price

Though the annual Wall of Remembrance candlelighting ceremony was canceled due to unforeseen circumstances, the site remained open to the public, as it does year-round. Many who paid their respects at Asser Levy Park walked over to the Wall of Remembrance afterward to continue their observances. The tribute, located on the western wall of Maimonides Park in Coney Island, is made up of three 30-by-12-foot granite panels, holding the laser-engraved portraits of 417 first responders. PAPD K-9 Sirius is also honored on the wall.

Candles, flowers and balloons adorn Brooklyn’s Wall of Remembrance in Coney Island on 9/11.Photo By Erica Price

American Veterans Memorial Pier in Bay Ridge

Over 100 people gathered at the American Veterans Memorial Pier in Bay Ridge on Wednesday to remember the victims of the attacks. Law enforcement officials, servicemembers, and elected leaders spoke to the crowd, which waved American flags and solemnly gazed across the Manhattan skyline, with the beaming tower lights in view.

Chief Fire Marshal Daniel Flynn, a lifelong Bay Ridge resident, emphasized the deep connection his community has to the events of that day.

“In this neighborhood, you find no shortage of streets renamed for FDNY and NYPD heroes who responded on Sept. 11, 2001,” Flynn said. “For 23 years we have mourned and grieved our loved ones … We will never forget who we have lost, what was sacrificed that day, and what we continue to sacrifice 23 years later, as our members continue to suffer from World Trade Center illnesses.”

People gather for a 9/11 vigil at the American Veterans Memorial Pier in Bay Ridge on Sept. 11, 2024.Photo by Paul Frangipane
Locals came together to commemorate the 23rd anniversary of 9/11 in Bay Ridge.Photo by Paul Frangipane

The Bay Ridge community, particularly known for its strong ties to first responders, has been uniquely affected by the aftermath of the attacks, as many continue to suffer from illnesses related to their service that day.

“One of the reasons why our community has felt the loss so disproportionately is because we are a community full of first responders, some of whom have passed from cancer in the decades since,” Council Member Justin Brannan said. “Here in southern Brooklyn, especially in Bay Ridge, it feels like we couldn’t possibly forget, because the loss is still ongoing.”

Captain Kristen Schafer of the 68th Precinct commended the community for its commitment to remembrance.

“This community comes together every year, year after year, and honors their vow to never forget,” she said. “For the moms, dads, wives and husbands, children who never got to live another day with their loved ones, we remember.”

Captain Kristen Schafer of the 68th Precinct speaks during the vigil.Photo by Paul Frangipane

State Senator Andrew Gounardes spoke about the evolving nature of the pain felt by those who lived through 9/11.

“The pain we feel as individuals and as a community never fully disappears, it merely evolves and changes as we all do over time,” he said. “The best way to honor the memory of those we lost is to work toward a better future for everyone.”

The vigil concluded with a moment of silence, as attendees gripped plastic candles and reflected on the lives lost, all vowing to “never forget.”

Other commemorations

A Brooklyn firehouse honored several of its own on Wednesday, and Green-Wood honored the more than 100 killed on 9/11 who rest at the historic cemetery with a program on the hill overlooking the Tribute in Light.

Members of Engine Company 214 and Tower Ladder 111 in Bedford-Stuyvesant remembered five firefighters who were killed during the terrorist attacks on Sept. 11, 2001, when hijacked planes struck the World Trade Center, killing nearly 3,000 people and devastating the city.

“This is a firehouse that is steeped in tradition,” Tower Ladder 111’s Steve McKinney told Brooklyn Paper. “Every time I get on the rig, I take a look at their pictures hanging on the wall to remember their commitment to excellence.”

9/11 at brooklyn firehouse
Members of Engine Company 214 and Tower Ladder 111 stand solemnly as they honor five fallen comrades who died during the 9/11 attacks.Photo by Lloyd Mitchell

Green-Wood’s memorial included words of remembrance, music and a reading of the names of victims buried at Green-Wood.

Other commemorations included the Seth Low Park Memorial, hosted by Assembly Member William Colton and Council Member Susan Zhuang in Bensonhurst; the FDNY Battalion 57 Memorial Mass, held at the Co-Cathedral of St. Joseph in Prospect Heights; St. Ann’s Annual Interfaith Service in Brooklyn Heights; and the Brooklyn-Bedford Park 9/11 Memorial Committee’s annual candlelight vigil at Bill Brown Park in Sheepshead Bay.

Additional reporting by Arthur de Gaeta, Paul Frangipane, Erica Price, Lloyd Mitchell and Kirstyn Brendlen