Man who pretended to be Bushwick homeowner’s nephew to steal deed gets 10 years in prison: DA

bushwick home that had deed stolen
A man who pretended to be a Bushwick homeowner’s nephew to fake Power of Attorney and steal the deed to her home has been sentenced to up to ten years in prison.
Cate Corcoran

A man who stole an elderly Bushwick homeowner’s deed and sold her home by pretending to be her nephew and forging Power of Attorney has been sentenced to up to ten years in prison.

Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez said Tuesday that 48-year-old Shavard Callaway of North Babylon “callously took advantage of an elderly woman, stealing and selling her home while she was living with relatives.”

“Today’s sentence holds him accountable for this despicable crime and sends a strong message to would-be scammers and deed thieves that we will seek serious penalties for those who victimize Brooklyn homeowners,” Gonzalez said in a press release.

brooklyn DA eric gonzalez
Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez said the sentence should come as a warning for other would-be deed thieves. File photo by Paul Frangipane

Callaway was convicted by a jury of grand larceny, forgery, and other charges after he stole the two-story house at 654 Chauncey Street from its 89-year-old homeowner in November 2014. The next month, he sold it to WI Management LLC, signed for by Moshe Weiss, for $250,000, city records show.

According to city records, the house had belonged to Nell Carter and had been in her family since 1968. At the time the deed was signed over to Callaway, Carter was living with relatives in upstate New York, Gonzalez said.

Carter discovered what had happened in January 2015 when prospective buyers, who were in contract to purchase the house from her for $900,000, did a title check and discovered the falsified deed.

Carter immediately filed a lawsuit against Callaway, who was indicted in November 2017, Gonzalez said. Callaway’s attorney negotiated a surrender, but Callaway failed to turn up and wasn’t arrested until he was found in Suffolk County in 2020. Gonzalez called Callaway a “predicate felon” and said he boasted on Facebook “that he had turned from his life of crime selling drugs to committing forgery and theft as a ‘paperwork master.’”

According to city records, the deed was returned to Carter’s estate in December 2019, as she died in 2015, and WI Management was reimbursed its $250,000 by the title company, Gonzalez said in the press release. Carter’s estate sold the property for $750,000 to First Chaunce Corp in February 2020, city records show.

First Chaunce Corp. renovated the wood-frame house, replacing its vinyl siding with brick veneer, and flipped it in July 2022, selling it to Townhouse Rental II LLC for $1.425 million, city records show. Townhouse Rental II, as the name suggests, appears to be an absentee investor: Days after the sale, the two units were advertised for rent, for more than $3,000 each. The company is associated with Freestone Property Group and Greenbrook Partners, a notoriously predatory landlord. 

Deed theft is an obstinate problem in Brooklyn, where thieves target elderly and Black and brown homeowners. As house prices have skyrocketed in much of central and eastern Brooklyn over the past 20 years, so too have scams that transfer homes from longtime owners, who get nothing or in some cases a fraction of their market value.

Gonzalez told BK Reader in July 2022 that his office’s Real Estate Fraud Unit “vigorously investigates deed fraud cases” but they can be “very difficult to prove.”

the house that was the subject of the deed theft
The home was eventually returned to Carter’s estate, and has since been sold again. Cate Corcoran

“Whenever there is sufficient evidence, we aggressively prosecute to ensure accountability and compensation for victims. To bring criminal charges, we must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that either a false filing took place or that the buyer made materially false representations of fact to induce the owner into selling the property,” he said.

Meanwhile, in October, the office of Attorney General Letitia James’ called on New York lawmakers to make deed theft an explicit crime in the state penal code, City Limits reported.

“No one should face the nightmare of having their home stolen from them without any warning, knowledge, or reason,” James said in press release announcing arrests in a separate deed theft case. “Deed theft is a merciless crime that targets seniors, and often people of color, who are asset rich but cash poor, and reliant on their homes as a stabilizing force for their families and loved ones.”

This story first appeared on Brooklyn Paper’s sister site Brownstoner