Fifth Avenue food cart war

Food cart fracas: Dispute over Halal cart ends in injuries

for The Brooklyn Paper
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

A scrape over a Bay Ridge sidewalk escalated into an all-out war last Saturday, when a controversial halal cart mowed down a Fifth Avenue bar owner during a fight over a coveted corner spot, witnesses claim.

Sammy Kassen, manager of the Middle Eastern Halal Cart, was trying to reclaim his food wagon’s location at the corner of Fifth Avenue and 86th Street on March 24, a spot taken away from him after someone quietly placed two benches atop his normal hangout under the cover of darkness, when several merchants, including Lone Star Bar owner Tony Gentile — a longtime critic of Kassen’s cart — created a human barricade, preventing him from backing in.

Kassen moved aside several newspaper boxes — a Bay Ridge Courier bin among them — and was maneuvering into the spot he made for himself when he reportedly backed into Gentile.

Imam Hassanain, who works at the Halal Express Food stand across the street, said he saw Gentile fall.

“A guy was blocking him saying ‘you can’t come in here,’ then he brought the cart in and knocked the guy down,” Hassanain remembered.

An FDNY spokesman said an ambulance brought someone suffering from arm and leg injuries from 86th Street and Fifth Avenue to Lutheran Medical Center at 4:35 pm. Cops from the 68th Precinct were also responded to a verbal altercation and assault, but no arrests were made.

Gentile declined to comment for this story.

Kassen said the merchants didn’t want him setting up shop near the corner.

“They were saying, ‘Hey, you can’t come in here.’ We said, ‘We just want to do business,’” Kassen said. “We got out and we argued, and there was a crowd blooming around us.”

A police source said that Middle Eastern’s permits are in order, so, if any charges were filed, Gentile would have been taken away in handcuffs since he was preventing a permitted merchant from doing business on a city sidewalk.

Councilman Vincent Gentile (D-Bay Ridge) — who is not related to the bar owner — was getting a haircut at a nearby barbershop when the conflict broke out and tried to mediate the dispute, according to spokesman Justin Brannan.

“He just tried to cool things down, until cooler heads could prevail,” Brannan said. “The whole situation needs to be worked out by the business improvement district.”

Fifth Avenue merchants have been complaining about the Middle Eastern Halal Cart for months, claiming that the gyro seller pollutes the sidewalk, attracts rowdy drunks, and gets off without paying the same steep rents as brick-and-mortar restaurants.

In fact, Gentile was hoping to uproot the food cart by installing flower beds on its prime piece of sidewalk real estate when the benches mysteriously popped up sometime after 4 am — after Kassen closed up shop for the night.

Kassen said that Middle Eastern wants to return to the spot it occupied prior to the benches’ enigmatic appearance, and that the business has been in touch with attorneys and city agencies about getting the new street seats unbolted from the pavement.

“We called 311, we called the Department of Transportation, and they all said the same thing — these benches are illegal and they’re looking into it,” Kassen said.

Updated 5:31 pm, July 9, 2018
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook

Don’t miss our updates:

Reasonable discourse

GrigoryLeps from Fort Hamilton says:
Lonestar has set up a table in the hallal spot and are engaging in a propoganda campaign as we speak, telling passers-by that the hallal food is no good and that they don't pay taxes.
Tony Gentile and his Lonestar posse are all racist. They are grand manipulators and schemers!
Tony is very good with the corrupt 68pct. He is pretty much untouchable.
It's so sad!
Community 10 Board has sided with Lonestar.
The Hallal guys have every right to be there!
April 30, 2012, 1:26 pm
Tom sackett from Carroll Gardens says:
I don't understand the problem here. Why is tony being a dick? And whoever says that they make the streets dirty is being ignorant, There is a halal food cart on 54th and 5th or 6th avenue in the city and they have lines around the entire block because there food is clean, delicious and cheap. When I go there the floors are always clean. I work in Williamsburg and the people here on Bedford are the worst with food but thats because there ——ing stupid and drunk. #teamsammy Life is a big game and we're all players. If you cheat than you lose. That's what tony did, he cheated by doing that. Who the hell puts benches there!?! Karma is a —— and she's going to love Tony
May 2, 2012, 1:12 am
samurppss from bayridge says:
loooooooool at TOM SACKETT love your answer.....everyone here who wants to these carts removed are a bunch of biased people and you cant handle compition you are all crying that they dont pay rent??? a store in manhatten pays rent 3 times more than a store here in brooklyn go and protest and have their store closed down... and i am sure the people here that are crying they dont want the carts here have eaten there when you wanted something quick and no damn restaurant was open or you just didnt feel like waiting so shut your pie hole and stuff it with halal food it is good for you.... i hope they come back and tony gets slapped with a law suite or just better yet slapped... and yes i love their foood yum yum yummmm
May 2, 2012, 10 am
Sheldon from Bay Ridge says:
On the July third I went to get a order of food in the Halal chicken cart on 86 Street and 5th ave next to the Chase bank. I was waiting on the line to order my food and i noticed the sweat from the cooks forehead falling on the food. I left, its very disgusting.
July 4, 2012, 9:25 pm
Ana from Bensonhurst says:
May I remind all of you Christians out there, you can not eat Halal, it's against our teachings..As for these trucks I find the dirty, these people pee in a can when your not looking...
Aug. 14, 2013, 8:02 pm

Comments closed.

First name
Last name
Your neighborhood
Email address
Daytime phone

Your letter must be signed and include all of the information requested above. (Only your name and neighborhood are published with the letter.) Letters should be as brief as possible; while they may discuss any topic of interest to our readers, priority will be given to letters that relate to stories covered by The Brooklyn Paper.

Letters will be edited at the sole discretion of the editor, may be published in whole or part in any media, and upon publication become the property of The Brooklyn Paper. The earlier in the week you send your letter, the better.

Keep it local!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter: